Virtual Extortion: Give me Back my Cartoon Beagle!
Last Thursday I attempted to log into my Second Life account during my Show and Tell session and was unable to connect. I assumed it was because I was a few versions behind, and so I completed the update and tried again, without success. I thought maybe I was using the wrong password, so I changed the password, tried again and still could not get in. I submitted a help ticket and received the following response:
Hello Jennifer,
Thank you for contacting Linden Lab support regarding your issue.
The reason you cannot login is that your account has been cancelled. The reason it was cancelled is due to the outstanding balance on the account which was not paid.
I can reactivate the account for you, but unfortunately all of the inventory, land and Linden dollars on the account will be gone.
If you would like me to do this, please reopen this ticket.
If you have any further questions you can contact myself or one of my colleagues.
Regards,
Shaun
Linden Lab support
Back in June, I changed my account from premium to basic, so was surprised they suggested I owed money. I wrote to @fleep, the SL goddess and wondered what she thought. She contacted the concierge for Chilbo, as I am a resident, and was told I had to contact the help desk myself. She was able to see my avatar information, so we assumed it had not been deleted. I replied to the original help request and received this response:
Hello Jennifer,
Thank you for contacting Linden Lab support regarding your issue.
Your account was a quarterly account, and you failed to downgrade before the fee was due. That is why there was an outstanding balance.
As mentioned before all of your land, inventory and Linden dollars on the account will have been deleted as the system to does this automatically.
I can reactivate this account for you, but you will have to pay the balance due on the account. If you would like me to do this, please reopen this ticket.
If you have any further questions you can contact myself or one of my colleagues.Regards,
Shaun
Linden Lab support
I decided just to call and see what would happen. I was quickly connected to Bruno, who advised me I had downgraded my account on 6/15, the same day my quarterly billing occurred. Since there was no longer a card on the account, it did not clear. They tried for 7 days, and since they couldn’t obtain payment, they canceled my account. Apparently, there are many levels of cancel, and your stuff is not deleted all at once. He advised me it may all be gone, or there could still be lindens and inventory available. He could not make promises.
Bruno told me I had to pay the $22 in order to get my avatar back. However, he could not promise I would have my inventory, or even my more than $14,000 Lindens. I admit, I was laughing too hard to even communicate with him. I asked if he realized he was holding my cartoon hostage! He told me that life was funny and Second Life was even funnier. I paid the $22, logged back in and discovered all my inventory in tact. That’s right, I didn’t lose my octopus family, my ball gowns, rocket launcher, beagle, fancy hair, alien eyes or bulletin board.
It really got me thinking about how SL is used in education and how we can trust building materials and storing them in SL. Much of what is created there cannot be transferred to any other platform. Educators put hours and hours of work into developing objects and content in-world, but there it remains. I didn’t have any important content in-world, but can imagine how much stronger my shock would have been if I had. I primarily have used SL from the social side, and it has been one of those social objects I value, as I participate in learning it with other educators. That is why I paid the ridiculous fee to restore my account.
I don’t think I really want to support instructors through anything similar. How can I ask them to invest time and effort in something that isn’t translatable or transferable? How can I ask them to give up their creations this way? Not only that, but it is so much easier to develop and share open resources on other web platforms. I still haven’t given up on SL, but I’m going to need a lot more convincing before I lead others there. I’ve now been studying it for almost two years, and still have that uncomfortable feeling.




